
Most signed documents never reach a court. But on the day one does, the question is always the same: "I didn't sign that" or "that's not what I signed". With paper, the argument is about the handwriting. With an e-signature, it is about the data surrounding the signature. Understanding how the evidence works lets you organise today what you will need tomorrow. This article is not a substitute for a lawyer's advice, but it gives you the map.
The starting point: an e-signature is admissible
Article 25.1 of Regulation (EU) 910/2014 (eIDAS) prevents a signature from being denied legal effect or admissibility as evidence merely because it is electronic or because it is not qualified. A judge cannot reject a document just because it is not on paper. You have already won that point, and we explain it on the legal validity page.
The real issue is a different one: what happens if the other party challenges the document, that is, disputes that it is authentic, that it is intact or that the date is the one it states.
What the Ley de Enjuiciamiento Civil says
Article 326 of the Ley de Enjuiciamiento Civil (Spain's Civil Procedure Act) governs the evidential weight of private documents, and Ley 6/2020 (the Spanish law on certain aspects of electronic trust services) added specific rules for electronic documents (its article 3.2 refers to those paragraphs):
- If nobody challenges it, the private document is full proof (paragraph 1).
- If it is challenged and a non-qualified trust service was used, paragraph 3 refers to the procedure in paragraph 2: the party submitting the document may propose any useful and relevant means of proof and, if authenticity cannot be deduced, the court assesses it according to the rules of sound judgement.
- If a qualified trust service was used that appeared on the trusted list at the relevant time, the document is presumed to have the characteristic in dispute. The party challenging it must carry out the verification; if the result is negative, they pay the costs, and if the court considers the challenge reckless, it may impose a fine of between 300 and 1,200 euros (paragraph 4).
In other words: with a qualified service, the burden of proof is reversed. With a non-qualified one (the usual case for everyday company document signing), it is up to you to show that the signature is valid, and for that you need data.
What evidence is convincing
When an e-signature is disputed, what gets examined is the trail left by the process. These are the pieces that tend to carry weight:
| Evidence | What it shows |
|---|---|
| Digital fingerprint (hash) of the document | That the document presented is exactly the one that was signed |
| Date and time of each step | When it was sent, when it was opened and when it was signed |
| Identification of the signatory | Who the document was sent to and with what details |
| Verified OTP code | That whoever signed had that person's mobile phone |
| Earlier and later communications | That the person knew about the document and acted in line with it |
| Conduct of the parties | Payments, deliveries or work carried out according to what was signed |
This last point is often forgotten. If someone denies having signed an employment contract but has been receiving a salary under its terms for months, or denies a quote that they later partly paid, their conduct counts.
The role of the expert witness
In a serious challenge, it is common for an IT expert to be called in. Their job is to check that the evidence record is consistent: that the document's fingerprint matches, that the dates fit together and that there are no signs of tampering. The more complete, orderly and verifiable that record is, the easier it is for the expert to explain it and for the judge to understand it.
For the expert, it matters a great deal that the evidence was generated at the time of signing, automatically, and not reconstructed afterwards from emails or screenshots.
What to do from today
- Keep the signed document and its evidence together and unmodified. Do not reprint or reconvert the signed PDF.
- Use contact details provided by the signatory, and keep a record of where and when they gave them to you.
- Activate SMS verification on important documents.
- Define how long you keep each type of document, taking into account the limitation periods for what is being signed. If in doubt, ask your adviser.
- If the risk is very high (high-value transactions or parties who are already in dispute), consider a qualified service, whose providers you can look up in the Ministry's list of providers or in the European Commission's trusted list.
Mistakes that weaken the evidence
- Presenting only a screenshot or a "document signed" email.
- Having edited the document after signing, even just to correct a typo.
- Being unable to explain which number or address the document was sent to.
- Having lost the evidence record when changing software or supplier.
How InfoSign prepares you for that day
With InfoSign, every signed document carries a qualified timestamp and comes with its evidence document, which the company receives immediately alongside the signed document. It records the document's digital fingerprint (any later change is detected), the date and time of each step (sending, opening and signing), the identification of the signatory and the one-time code used to sign, which arrives by email and, if you activate it, also by SMS. And the document is digitised instantly on your server, without depending on someone filing it.
In other words, the trail an expert would examine is generated automatically at the moment of signing. See how the process works at e-signature of documents.


